Closed

Illustrator or Photoshop for digital drawing??

  • VIEW 841
  • Total 6
I am a digital artist. I didn't see a thread about difference between this two software , and it seemed like no one has given their impressions on this oftware so I wanted to put together something quick to kickstart a discussion or something.

Illustrator is a vector based application and Photoshop is an image editor. That means Photoshop works with pixels and Illustrator does not. Illustrator drawings can be scaled and printed at any size without loss of image quality. The lines are very clean and sharp, which is great for logo design and illustration. Photoshop drawings can be more similar to drawing with traditional media like pencils, or chalk, or paint, if that's what you want.

If you draw in Photoshop it is important to plan ahead for final output size. If you want to eventually print your drawing at 16" x 20", then you need to start with a document that big, at a resolution of at least 150 ppi (depending on how it will be printed). When you draw in Illustrator you don't have to worry about any of that in the beginning.

What kind of drawing are you trying to create? What's the final intent for the drawing? Do you want a super sharp clean edge drawing, or something more organic? You have to answer those questions before you can get the correct answer.

IF you decide that Photoshop is perfect for your drawing needs, then you must get a pressure sensitive drawing tablet . XP-Pen makes a affordable and well-built graphics tablets.

https://www.xp-pen.com/goods/lists/catid/118.html

I combine drawing and photography for my composite art. I start the old fashion way with pencil on paper, then color it in Photoshop. The final look is much different then something created in Illustrator. Here's my most recent drawing composite.

Von Glitschka is the best Illustrator artist I know. His work has a completely different look and style. He primarily works in Illustrator and has written several books and recorded several Lynda.com courses about his workflow.

Patrick Lamontagne is a cartoon artist who does all of his work in Photoshop, including the line drawing part. He also does photo realistic paintings completely with Photoshop.

I hope somebody can find this helpful. Let me know.

Published date : 11 months ago

Updated date : 11 months ago

English

Answer
  • Not applicable
    11 months ago
    Your impressions are precious.
    So what is the question?
    • Japanese

  • 11 months ago
    Perhaps you are wondering how to purchase xp - pen?
    • Japanese

  • 11 months ago
    This forum is not about posting threads about personal impressions of other digital software, products and artists
    (But please do check Affinity photo/designer software and browse through Artstation for some top art).
    This forum is a place where you can ask questions about CSP.

    Shameless XP-pen plug is funny.
    • English

  • 11 months ago
    The answer is CSP for digital drawing.
    I do everything in CSP.
    I have no need for vector illustrations or photoshop.
    I can do almost everything faster in CSP (except text) , brushes feel better, and there are tools which help me work more comfortably than in PS.
    CPS is designed for digital illustration not so much for color correction and retouching.
    Above all it's much cheaper than Adobe packages.
    • English

  • Not applicable
    11 months ago
    > To Memag
    Your remark "This forum does not post threads on personal impressions of other digital software, products, artists"
    It is surprising remark that I can not think that it is an evangelist certifier.
    Please read below.
    https://ask.clip-studio.com/en-us/help
    • Japanese

  • 11 months ago
    Fair enough ,
    in that case that was my personal opinion.
    The OP post didn't look like a genuine question more of a commercial plug for other products.

    My intentions were never malicious, I am just trying to help people understand things.
    I don't do backseat moderation or derail the threads.

    I also gave an answer to the question and provided reasons why.

    Thank you for your concern.

    • English

This question was closed.

Open questions in same division

...View more

Unanswered questions

...View more